Wednesday, January 15, 2020

difference - open to discuss(ing)


Until right now, I was very sure that the formulation (we are) open to discuss is kind of idiomatic. Now I read a text that (as I have been told) has been checked by a native speaker of English and stumbled over this:


We are open to discussing the opportunities with you.


I would have written


We are open to discuss the opportunities with you.


instead.



Before I am making a fool out of myself by wrongly correcting a native speaker: Those both seem grammatically fine to me, but I do not think the first version is normally used. Could you help me find out, if I am right?



Answer



The to in the idiom open to is a preposition, not an ‘infinitive marker’, so it requires a nominal entity as object of the preposition:



My door is open to [anyone who needs to speak with me].
We are open to [whatever proposal you wish to put forward].
The floor is now open to [discussion of this motion].



When you want to use a subordinate clause—a verb with its arguments—as the object, this idiom requires a gerund clause




We are open to [discussing the opportunities with you].



Expressions which employ the preposition to to head NP complements will usually not license infinitive complement clauses, because this creates an awkward ambiguity in the use of to.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...