Sunday, March 27, 2016

The definite article before nouns derived from verbs



Tell me please which of the following sentences is correct.



1 "His actions have raised concerns about monopolization of the industry."
2 "His actions have raised concerns about the monopolization of the industry."



I think the second is correct because "monopolization" is modified by "industry", but I have noticed sometimes people drop "the" before such sentences that is why I am confused by the usage of "the" before nouns from verbs and "of phrase".



Answer



They are both correctly-formed sentences, but given the context, the first is probably correct.


To explain, the first implies his actions have caused concerns to be raised that monopolization of the industry in question is happening. The second implies that his actions have caused concerns to have only just now been raised about the previously known about monopolization of the industry in question. Whilst the second scenario is not impossible, the first seems more likely. I should add that these implications are not 100% the only way of reading the two sentences, but seeing them side-by-side that is what the difference wold seem to imply.


The definite article in front of "monopolization" changes how that word is being used so it is not (directly at least) connected to the definite article in front of "industry", which changes how the word "industry" is being used.



No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...