Wednesday, July 1, 2015

meaning in context - Does placement of "not" have significance? Not to be verb, To not be verb, To be not verb


Question #1: What is the difference in meaning between "[to be] not invited" and similar negated forms? Is "to be not invited" an idiomatic form that has a meaning distinct from other ways of phrasing the lack of an invitation? Here are some examples from the Google search "to be not invited":




It seems this has a different meaning than other forms. For example, what is the difference in meaning between "Is John not going to be invited?" and "Is John going to be not invited?"


Question #2: Can this be generalized to other similar/parallel forms of negation "not to be verb" and "to be not verb" and other forms (see below)?


(These questions are inspired by the question, Is "To be not invited is sad" grammatical?)




In both Question 1 and Question 2, one may consider the following forms:



  • Not to be verb.

  • To not be verb.

  • To be not verb.

  • Any other form expressing a similar meaning.



Also, for this entire question/answer thread, one may attempt to creatively create contexts/scenarios in which there is a difference in meaning in order to explain how they could signify a difference.




No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...