Sunday, March 11, 2018

prepositions - Problem (with) doing something


When you want to say that you had or are having problems with something, what is the best way to express this:



I'm having a problem with saying this correctly.


I'm having a problem saying this correctly.



Another example:



There is a problem with sending this form.


There is a problem sending this form.





Answer



Either will be understood, and can be correct, but in my opinion the inclusion of the word "with" has a connotation of a more general problem.



There is a problem sending this form.



This probably implies that there is a specific problem with the form, that prevents it from being sent. Perhaps you forgot to include your last name, and the web site is rejecting it as invalid.



There is a problem with sending this form.




This could suggest a more general problem, which is preventing sending the form, or which may result from sending the form. It may not be a problem with the form directly, but perhaps your Internet connection is not working. Or perhaps your computer has caught fire. Or it may be that if you submit the form, a problem will arise--perhaps your employer will discover you are looking for work elsewhere.


with could also suggest a personal or moral objection, rather than a practical, problem:



I have a problem with going to strip clubs.
She had a problem with the way he sang.



No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...