Tuesday, February 18, 2020

question marks - How to use "to be" at the end of a sentence


I have some confusion about this; for example:



Where is the bank?



I don't know where the bank is.



I don't know how to be is used at the end of sentences.



Answer



Let's start with a basic sentence:



The bank is there.



We can turn this into a wh-question by replacing there with where:




The bank is where? (inappropriate in most circumstances)



This kind of question is acceptable in a few limited circumstances, but most wh-questions have two additional things done to them:




  1. wh-fronting. We move where to the front of the sentence:



    Where the bank is ____? (inappropriate in most circumstances)



    It leaves behind a gap, which I've marked with a blank (____). (The gap is usually not written.) The word where and the gap refer to the same thing. What's important is this: you can't add a complement after is because there's a gap there.



    "Where the bank is?" is only appropriate in a few limited circumstances, like if you're repeating something back to someone. It's usually incorrect. To fix it, we need to do one more thing:




  2. Subject-auxiliary inversion. The subject (the bank) and the auxiliary verb (is) switch places:



    Where is the bank ____?



    Subject-auxiliary inversion marks a sentence as a direct question. With both wh-fronting and subject-auxiliary inversion, we've created a complete question ("Where is the bank?").





However, if you want to use "where the bank is" as an indirect question, you don't switch the subject and auxiliary:



[ where the bank is ____ ]



This is a relative clause. It doesn't work as a direct question, which means it doesn't work as a sentence on its own. That's why I didn't capitalize where or put a period at the end. But it does work as an indirect question, as part of a larger declarative sentence:



I don't know [ where the bank is ____ ].



In this example, we've fronted where, but we did not invert the subject and auxiliary. That would be ungrammatical because it's not a direct question:




*I don't know [ where is the bank ____ ]. (ungrammatical)



(Technically, there are circumstances where it's possible to embed a direct question, particularly in speech. But I'm ignoring that here.)


No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...