Monday, May 8, 2017

verbs - Gerund & participle: "She stormed out, 'slamming' the door so hard that the mirror fell off the wall"



She stormed out, slamming the door so hard that the mirror fell off the wall.



As fa as I know, in Italian language slamming functions as a gerund there, but, very often—as it could be the case here—there is no parallelism between English and Italian when one compares gerund and participle forms.


So the question is: how can one figure out if in the above example "slamming" is a gerund or a participle?



Answer



In English the grammatical term gerund is used only for an -ING form which is employed as a noun. When an -ING form is used as an adjective or as a component of progressive verb construction it is called a participle.


Consequently, the way to tell what you should call a specific instance of an -ING form is to determine what role it plays in the sentence.


In the case at hand, slamming ... is a clause which describes what the subject she did. It is not the subject or object of another verb, it is not marked with a determiner or any other adjective. It has to be a participle.



In the same context you might use slamming as a gerund this way:



She stormed out; slamming the door so hard that the mirror fell off the wall was her final comment on the discussion.



In this case, *slamming ... * is the subject of the verb was; slamming is a gerund.


It is usually pretty easy to figure out whether an -ING form is a participle or a gerund; but there is one tricky sort of construction. These require a subtler analysis.



running water
running shoes




In both of these, running is used to modify the following noun; but in the first, running is a participle, while in the second it is a gerund.


This may be easier to understand if I introduce a new technical term. The -ING form is traditionally called the present participle, to distinguish it from the past participle, the -ED form; but it is just as proper, and sometimes more useful to call it an active participle: a form which designates what the noun it modifies does, as opposed to the passive participle, which designates what is done to the noun it modifies.


So to discern whether an -ING form is a participle or a gerund you must ask yourself whether the action the form names is performed by the noun which it modifies.



  • In running water it is in fact the water which runs, so running is a participle

  • in running shoes, however, the shoes do not run; rather, they are used for running, just as tennis shoes are used for playing tennis or football shoes are used for playing soccer. In this case, running is a verb used as a noun—a gerund—which in turn is used attributively, as an adjective.


Isn’t English fun?!


No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...