Saturday, August 19, 2017

sentence construction - Use of "From where" and "Where from"



I'm a little confused about which of the following sentence is correct. If both of them are correct, then when to use each of these?




  1. From where have you done your Bachelors?

  2. Where have you done your Bachelors from?




Answer



Do from is an ‘Indianism’, so use of this phrase must be referred to speakers of that dialect.


In Standard English we use at with the verb do; the preposition phrase names the place where the work was performed:




I did my doctorate at the University of Wisconsin.
He did an internship at Microsoft.



We use from in this context with receive; the preposition phrase names the entity which conferred the gift:



I received my doctorate from the University of Wisconsin.



In ordinary speech, however, we use the verb get, which may take either preposition phrase (though at is probably more common)




I got my bachelors at Vanderbilt.
I got my bachelors from Vanderbilt.



With do we use at;


In a question, no preposition at all is needed, whichever verb you use:



Where did you do your bachelors?
Where did you get your bachelors?
Where did you receive your bachelors?






By “Standard English” I mean English usage which will pass unnoticed with any educated native speaker—appropriate to its register and not dialectal, foreign, antiquated, or precious.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...