Monday, August 14, 2017

Missing article in this construction involving an uncountable noun


In this YouTube video from 1:00 to 1:06 the following sentence is said:



I can take anything that inspires me and make it part of our music.



Should there be the indefinite article a before part? Is it missing because music itself is uncountable? That doesn't make much sense because music can have many parts to it, so it seems that the indefinite article a is necessary.



Answer



The difference between part and a part has to do with the context and intent of the sentence, not the noun that the part is referencing.


According to ODO, the two most common definitions of part are:





  1. An amount or section which, when combined with others, makes up the whole of something:
    'divide the circle into three equal parts'

  2. Some but not all of something:
    'the painting tells only part of the story'
    Source: Oxford Dictionaries Online, "part"



Definition 1 comes off as more segmented and distinct than definition 2. Imagine definition 1 as talking about slices of a pie, and definition 2 as talking about ingredients mixed into a cake. Both are parts, but one is separable, the other is not.


When you say something is a part something, you are using definition 1. So to make something a part of our music means that we want to incorporate that specific element (dubstep wobble, or cowbell, for instance) into our music.



When you say something is part of something, you're using definition 2. So to make something part of our music means that we want to make it integral to our music, an inseparable defining element.


Hope this helps!


No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...