Monday, February 11, 2019

negation - agreement with so and neither


We agree with positive statements using so-too:



I have a red car.

(Sara) So does Sara



But with the negative statements we use neither-either:



I don't have a brother.
(Jhon) Neither does Jhon



So I can say that the most important thing before giving your agreement is to know whether the sentence is positive or negative and then to agree as I did in the examples above.
But these sentences let me think many times:




I have nothing to do.
(I) so do I
or
Neither do I



So the question is:
Should I consider the last sentence positive or negative?
Look at this sentence too:



The boy is impolite (It means that the boy is not polite)

(girl) so is the girl
or
Neither is the girl



I mean if there's a prefix (which changes the word to the opposite), then the sentence will be negative in meaning so either or neither is used?



Answer



There are only a few markers in English which make a question a "negative-polarity" question:



  • No

  • Not


  • Nothing

  • Never


And any of their combined/contracted forms ("cannot", "don't", wasn't", etc.)


If and only if any of these appear in the sentence, it is considered a negative-polarity sentence and the "agreeing" response uses "neither":




  • I had no idea.

  • I was not present at the time.

  • I had nothing to do with it.


  • I never heard any complaints.


agreeing reply = Me neither!



A prefix on a word which reverses its meaning, even "non-", does not convert the sentence to negative polarity:



He was very non-committal.
- So was she.



No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...