Sunday, August 23, 2015

grammar - Answering a question with "Me" instead of "I" +



I heard it from a movie.


Situation 1



Mommy: Who is ready for lunch?


A boy: I am.


A little girl : Me!



Situation 2



Mommy: Who wants to eat some ice cream?



A boy: I do.


A little girl : Me!



I think "me" is an object pronoun used after a verb or preposition.


Why can we use it for answering a question?


Are there any rules about using it?


And can we use "Me!" instead of I do./ I did./ I am. / I was. and so on to answering a question starting with "Who...?" like the example below?



Mommy : Who made a mess?


A little girl : Me!



A boy : Her! (And can the boy say "Her!" which means a little girl made a mess?)




Answer



In spoken English, object pronouns are also used as emphatic or referential pronouns.


For example, I typically think of myself as "me," and a group including me as "us." We use these emphatic or referential pronouns in any stand-alone statement (i.e. one without a verb), such as a quick answer to a question.


Thus "who wants to come?" You could say in response "Me." "Us." "Not us." or "Her" or "Not us, but maybe them." (note that with "you" there is no ambiguity since the subject and object pronouns are the same.) Saying "I" or "we" or "they" or "she" is ungrammatical. Saying "I do" or "they don't" is fine but is not what most English speakers would do.


In prescriptive grammar, this is frowned upon. Hence, for instance, you can find scorepads for card games labeled "we" and "they." In my opinion this style of speech sounds very unnatural. Unless you are writing a formal document, you should aim to talk like the child in the movie, if your goal is to sound more like a native speaker.


Similarly, in response to "Who's there?" "That's me." Or when a stranger calls you on the phone and asks "Is Sarah there?" If you are Sarah, you say "that's me." (Prescriptivists will tell you to say "this is she," but this again sounds extremely formal.)


No comments:

Post a Comment

Simple past, Present perfect Past perfect

Can you tell me which form of the following sentences is the correct one please? Imagine two friends discussing the gym... I was in a good s...